Untangling the Web of Permits for the Revell Site
Here in Northwestern Ontario, we often hear that the proposed Deep Geological Repository (DGR) is a federal project. But for those of us living in Melgund Township, Borups Corners, and Dyment, the reality of how this project gets approved is much more complicated than a single stamp from Ottawa. Whether it is the water in our wells, the traffic on Highway 17, or the wildlife in our backyards, understanding who holds the clipboard is essential for understanding our future.
What We Are Learning
The Nuclear Waste Management Organization (NWMO) has released details on the regulatory maze they must navigate. We are learning that the Revell Site isn’t just subject to one set of rules. It involves a three-tiered approach:
- Indigenous Jurisdiction: The Wabigoon Lake Ojibway Nation (WLON) is applying its own Regulatory Assessment and Approvals Process (RAAP), grounded in Anishinaabe law.
- Federal Law: The project is designated as a "Class 1B nuclear facility," meaning the heavy lifting is done under the Nuclear Safety and Control Act and the Impact Assessment Act.
- Provincial Permits: There is a long list of potential Ontario permits required for things like sewage works, taking water, road entrances, and protecting species at risk.
The Reality Check
While the list of regulations looks comprehensive, a closer look at the Impact Assessment documents reveals a significant grey area.
What is being promised: The NWMO lists numerous provincial permits (like the Endangered Species Act or Ontario Water Resources Act) that usually protect our local environment.
What we need to verify: The documents explicitly state that provincial requirements are "inoperative" if they conflict with federal nuclear laws. This creates uncertainty. If the Province says "do not disturb this wetland" but the Federal nuclear regulator says "we need to build here for safety," who wins? Right now, the documentation suggests the federal government could override local provincial protections, and that is a detail we need to watch closely.
The Path Forward
This uncertainty creates a risk for our community. The report notes that discussions on the applicability of Ontario laws "have not yet occurred," leaving a gap in how environmental standards will be enforced.
The Solution: We are calling for a formal Jurisdictional Coordination Plan. The NWMO and regulators must map out exactly where federal and provincial rules overlap and agree on a hierarchy before approval is granted. We need a written guarantee that the highest standard of environmental protection will apply, regardless of whether it is a federal or provincial rule. This ensures that "nuclear safety" isn’t used as a loophole to bypass local environmental safeguards.
Why It Matters Here
Why should a resident in Melgund Township worry about jurisdictional legalities? Because it affects our daily life. If the project needs to drain a local water source or alter a moose habitat, we need to know that the Ontario Ministry of the Environment still has the power to say "no," or if they can be overruled by federal nuclear priorities. Clarifying this protects our hunting, fishing, and water security.
Have Your Say
This affects our future. Submit your feedback on this specific issue via our Engage page to ensure the Impact Assessment Agency hears from our community.
The Melgund Integrated Nuclear Impact Assessment Project
The Impact Assessment Agency of Canada (IAAC) is reviewing the Nuclear Waste Management Organization’s (NWMO) proposed Deep Geological Repository (DGR) at the Revell Site, located near Ignace and Wabigoon Lake Ojibway Nation in Northwestern Ontario.
This major nuclear infrastructure project is undergoing a joint federal review by the IAAC and the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) to evaluate environmental, health, social, and Indigenous rights impacts over its projected 160-year lifecycle.
Public Feedback Open: Comments on the Initial Project Description are accepted until February 4, 2026. Submissions help shape the formal impact assessment guidelines.
This short article and summary is based on an initial analysis of a proponent’s initial project description. It does not represent, any community the NWMO or the Government of Canada. Learn more at the Melgund Integrated Nuclear Impact Assessment Project project page.
About the Author
