Keeping Eyes on the Ground in Northwestern Ontario
For those of us living in Melgund Township, Borups Corners, and Dyment, the environment isn’t just scenery—it’s our pantry, our playground, and our heritage. When we read about the proposed Revell Site for a Deep Geological Repository, the biggest question on many neighbours’ minds is: "Who is watching the shop?" Specifically, if something goes wrong with the water or the land, how quickly will we know, and who decides how to fix it?
We have been reviewing the latest Impact Assessment documents from the Nuclear Waste Management Organization (NWMO) regarding their Environmental Management System. Here is what they are proposing for our corner of Northwestern Ontario.
What We Are Learning
The NWMO has outlined a governance structure called an "Environmental Management System" (EMS). In plain English, this is the rulebook they intend to follow to keep the project safe. They have committed to meeting all Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) requirements and following various CSA standards for monitoring water, air, and ground conditions.
A core part of their plan is something called "Adaptive Management." This means that if their monitoring picks up an unexpected change in the environment, they have a system in place to change their operations to fix it. Essentially, they plan to learn as they go and adjust their methods if the data shows that their current protections aren’t working as well as predicted.
The Reality Check
While a flexible plan sounds good on paper, we need to look closer at the details to ensure our community is truly protected.
What is being promised: The NWMO states they will use the "best available technology and techniques economically achievable" to control releases into the environment.
What we need to verify: The phrase "economically achievable" is a heavy qualifier. We need to ensure that cost-cutting never takes precedence over safety. Furthermore, without a specific list of what technologies are considered "best," it is difficult for us to judge if the proposed protections are actually sufficient for a project of this magnitude.
What is being promised: They will use "Adaptive Management" to handle unforeseen effects.
What we need to verify: Relying too heavily on fixing problems after they appear can be risky. We need to ensure this isn’t used as a loophole to bypass rigorous planning today. We need to know exactly what constitutes an "unacceptable" impact before the project even begins.
The Path Forward
In reviewing the technical gaps, we see two major areas where Melgund Township and our neighbours need to push for better definitions.
The Gap: The current plan relies on internal governance. There is no mention of independent community oversight or the inclusion of Indigenous Knowledge in the monitoring data.
The Solution: We are calling for the integration of Community-Based Monitoring. We need a collaborative process where local residents and Indigenous groups help select the monitoring sites and interpret the data. We shouldn’t just be told the water is safe; we should be involved in testing it.
The Gap: The "Adaptive Management" strategy is vague on specifics.
The Solution: The proponent must provide a detailed plan with specific "action levels" and "triggers." We need to know exactly which environmental indicators will be watched and what specific, pre-authorized actions will be taken if those indicators blink red. This moves the plan from general promises to concrete guarantees.
Why It Matters Here
In Northwestern Ontario, a "minor" change in groundwater or a shift in local wildlife patterns affects our daily lives. If the monitoring system is designed entirely by people in offices far away, they might miss the subtle signs that a local hunter or angler would spot immediately. Ensuring that the Impact Assessment includes local eyes and ears isn’t just about being polite—it’s about ensuring the safety data is accurate and relevant to the people living right next to the Revell Site.
Have Your Say
This affects our future. Submit your feedback on this specific issue via our Engage page to ensure the Impact Assessment Agency hears from our community.
The Melgund Integrated Nuclear Impact Assessment Project
The Impact Assessment Agency of Canada (IAAC) is reviewing the Nuclear Waste Management Organization’s (NWMO) proposed Deep Geological Repository (DGR) at the Revell Site, located near Ignace and Wabigoon Lake Ojibway Nation in Northwestern Ontario.
This major nuclear infrastructure project is undergoing a joint federal review by the IAAC and the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) to evaluate environmental, health, social, and Indigenous rights impacts over its projected 160-year lifecycle.
Public Feedback Open: Comments on the Initial Project Description are accepted until February 4, 2026. Submissions help shape the formal impact assessment guidelines.
This short article and summary is based on an initial analysis of a proponent’s initial project description. It does not represent, any community the NWMO or the Government of Canada. Learn more at the Melgund Integrated Nuclear Impact Assessment Project project page.
About the Author
